Mediation in commercial construction dispute resolution
Mediation has been very much a part of the dispute resolution landscape in the construction industry for over 30 years. On 1 October 2024, a historic change to the status of alternative dispute resolution in the civil justice system took effect. Amendments to the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) came into force to promote the use of alternative dispute resolution including mediation. The amendments bring the rules in line with the Court of Appeal decision in James Churchill -v- Merthyr Tydfil County Borough Council [2023].

As a result of the amendments the use of mediation is likely to increase significantly – but when is the best time to mediate?
Gowling WLG, in collaboration with the University of Manchester, are undertaking a groundbreaking research project, the aim of which is to investigate when parties mediate their disputes. What are the influences on the decision-making process? Will the new Amendments to the CPR have any impact on timing?The start of the research project is a short questionnaire that will enable the collection of data from those using mediation. This will be invaluable to the whole research project.
Take part in the research
To take part, we’re looking for participants with practical experience of the use and timing of mediation in commercial dispute resolution. If you fit the criteria you can answer our survey by clicking on this link. We look forward to your valuable input.
This research attempts to collect data from professionals who have practical experience of the use and timing of mediation in commercial dispute resolution. If you are interested but have no genuine experience, please email the researchers peter.fenn@manchester.ac.uk or obuks.ejohwomu@manchester.ac.uk
You are being invited to take part in an online questionnaire/survey about the use and timing of mediation in dispute resolution. The research is being carried out at the University of Manchester in collaboration with Gowling WLG, a multinational law firm. Gowling WLG's involvement is limited to circulation of the questionnaire, and they will have no access to the data you provide. In any event the questionnaire is anonymous and confidential and no personal identifiable is collected [we do NOT collect your IP address].
Participant Information Sheet (PIS)
Before you decide whether to take part, it is important for you to understand why the research is being conducted and what it will involve. Please take time to read the following information carefully before deciding whether to take part and discuss it with others if you wish. Please ask if there is anything that is not clear or if you would like more information. Thank you for taking the time to read this.
About the research
Who will conduct the research?
What is the purpose of the research?
Mediation is now an established part of dispute resolution in the construction industry however there is little or no empirical evidence of when it takes place.
We seek to find:
- When does it take place?
- During the duration of the contract/post contract completion
- Agreeing the Final Account
- Pre Action-Protocol Process
- During the proceedings
- "Just before" trial
- Why dos it take place when it does?
- Is this too late?
- Are significant costs already spent?
- Why do parties not mediate in real time?