Jessica Tresham
Partner
Article
6
In Vivid Housing Ltd v Allianz Global Corporate & Specialty SE [2026], the Court of Appeal considered when passive fire safety defects, such as combustible cladding, missing cavity barriers or debris in cavities, can amount to "the threat of imminent destruction or physical damage" under a housing warranty insurance policy, potentially triggering cover before any fire has actually occurred.
The Court confirmed that the test is whether, viewed objectively, the damage is sufficiently likely to happen sufficiently soon. Whether that threshold is met is a question of fact and degree.
We examine the background to the dispute, the parties' arguments, the Court of Appeal's decision and what the judgment means for policyholders and insurers dealing with fire safety defects.
Clause 3(a) of the policy provided an indemnity for the cost of repairing, replacing and/or strengthening the Premises following a Defect which becomes manifest and is notified during the Period of Insurance, causing:
"(i) destruction of the Premises; or (ii) physical damage to the Premises; or (iii) the threat of imminent destruction or physical damage to the Premises which requires immediate remedial measures for theprevention of destruction or physical damage within the Period of Insurance."
No fire had occurred, so the claim depended entirely on limb (iii).
Allianz argued that the judge had construed clause 3(a)(iii) so that damage by fire is always "imminent", depriving the words "imminent" and "immediate" of any effective meaning. Applying the ordinary meaning of those words, a threat had to be both likely to happen and likely to happen sufficiently soon, and had to require remedial measures before the end of the Period of Insurance. Allianz also pointed to Vivid's claim form, which answered "N/A" when asked whether urgent repairs were required, and to the fact that only a waking watch had followed.
Vivid countered that the threat of fire is constant and arises from a multitude of everyday causes. The defects meant that an ordinary fire could spread unseen and uninhibited around the building, with potentially catastrophic consequences.
At first instance, Jefford J had held that the question was whether, at the relevant time (August 2019, the date of the fire risk report), "the risk of fire was sufficiently serious and would eventuate sufficiently soon". She considered that requiring the insured to show that a fire was about to break out would not be a commercial construction, since the policy would then hardly ever respond to fire risk.
The Court of Appeal (Stuart-Smith LJ, with whom Phillips LJ and Peter Jackson LJ agreed) unanimously dismissed the appeal, observing that "the longer the hearing of this appeal lasted, the less there appeared to be between the parties". It held that:
These were, in the Court's words, "paradigm matters for resolution at a trial, not on a summary judgment application".
The decision comes as Parliament considers the Building Safety (Remediation of Unsafe Cladding etc) Bill, introduced on 14 October 2026, which would impose duties to assess fire risks, carry out remedial works and introduce interim safety measures. We considered the Bill in detail in our insight: Remediation Bill: new duties, tougher enforcement and greater accountability. For building owners facing remediation costs, latent defects policies may be a valuable avenue of recovery.
For advice on latent defects insurance, building safety or construction disputes generally, please get in touch with Jessica Tresham, Sam Holland, or Jatinder Sahota.
CECI NE CONSTITUE PAS UN AVIS JURIDIQUE. L'information qui est présentée dans le site Web sous quelque forme que ce soit est fournie à titre informatif uniquement. Elle ne constitue pas un avis juridique et ne devrait pas être interprétée comme tel. Aucun utilisateur ne devrait prendre ou négliger de prendre des décisions en se fiant uniquement à ces renseignements, ni ignorer les conseils juridiques d'un professionnel ou tarder à consulter un professionnel sur la base de ce qu'il a lu dans ce site Web. Les professionnels de Gowling WLG seront heureux de discuter avec l'utilisateur des différentes options possibles concernant certaines questions juridiques précises.
Gowling WLG est un cabinet juridique international constitué des membres de Gowling WLG International Limited, une société à responsabilité limitée par garanties enregistrée en Angleterre, ainsi que leurs affiliés respectifs. Les membres et affiliés constituent des entités autonomes et indépendantes. Gowling WLG International Limited promeut, facilite et coordonne les activités de ses membres, mais ne fournit pas elle-même de services aux clients. Pour en savoir davantage sur notre structure, consultez notre page Avis juridique.
© 2026 Gowling WLG Tous droits réservés